Compare Machines


	Nuova Simonelli	Lucca
MSRP
MSRP	$1495	$2595
Skill Level
Skill Level	Intermediate	Advanced
Type
Type	Semi-Automatic	Semi-Automatic
Heating Element
Heating Element	Heat Exchanger	Dual Boiler
Portafilter Size
Portafilter Size	58 mm	53 mm
Activation
Activation	Button	Button
Pump Type
Pump Type	Vibration	Rotary
Heat-Up Time
Heat-Up Time	5-15 Minutes	5-15 Minutes
Brew Boiler Capacity Note: The Oscar II pulls brew water directly from reservoir
Brew Boiler Capacity	Brew: Not Applicable Heat Exchanger machines pull brew water directly from reservoir	Brew: 0.45L
Steam Boiler Capacity
Steam Boiler Capacity	Steam: 2L	Steam: 1.2L
Water Supply
Water Supply	2.8 L - Reservoir	2.4 L - Direct Connect
Boiler Material
Boiler Material	Copper	Nickel Plated Brass
Brew Group Material
Brew Group Material	No Information	No Information
Hot Water
Hot Water	No	Yes
Steam Wand
Steam Wand	Yes	Yes
No-Burn Wand
No-Burn Wand	No	Yes
PID Temperature Control
PID Temperature Control	No	Yes
Pre-Infusion
Pre-Infusion	No	Yes
Shot Timer
Shot Timer	No	No
Concurrent Brew Steam
Concurrent Brew Steam	Yes	Yes
Flow Control
Flow Control	No	No
3 Way Solenoid
3 Way Solenoid	Yes	Yes
Brew Pressure Guage
Brew Pressure Gauge	No	Yes
Steam Pressure Guage
Steam Pressure Guage	No	Yes
Over Pressure Valve
Over Pressure Valve	Yes	Yes
Integrated Grinder
Integrated Grinder	No	No
Weight
Weight	17.7 kg	28 kg
Material
Material	Stainless Steel, Plastic	Stainless Steel

EspressoBot Comparison

Machine Overview

The Lucca A53 Direct Plumb is priced at $2,595 and is classified as an advanced skill-level semi-automatic espresso machine. In contrast, the Nuova Simonelli Oscar II is more budget-friendly at $1,495 and is designed for intermediate skill levels. Both machines are made from stainless steel, indicating a certain level of quality and durability. The Lucca machine is positioned as more suited for seasoned baristas, while the Oscar II appeals to those with some experience.

Brewing Comparison

In terms of brewing information, the Lucca A53 uses a dual boiler heating element and features a saturated group type with a heat-up time ranging from 5 to 15 minutes. Its water source is a direct connection, allowing for a consistent flow. On the other hand, the Oscar II employs a heat exchanger and has a water reservoir capacity of 2.8 liters, also with a heat-up time of 5 to 15 minutes. While the Lucca has a brew boiler capacity of 0.45 liters, the Oscar II does not specify a brew boiler capacity.

Features Comparison

Regarding key features, the Lucca A53 includes several advanced capabilities such as PID control, pre-infusion, and smart connectivity, enhancing its functionality for skilled users. In contrast, the Oscar II is simpler, lacking features like PID control and hot water functionality but still supports concurrent brewing and steaming. Both machines feature solenoid valves, steam wands, and over-pressure valves, although the Lucca's design includes a no-burn wand for safer operation. Overall, the Lucca presents a more refined set of features suitable for dedicated espresso enthusiasts, while the Oscar II caters to those who appreciate quality at a more accessible price point.

Note: Espresso Setup Chris is expirementing with generated summaries for dynamic pages (we have 10,000+ so I can't write for all of them!) If you found this useful, or awful, please shoot me an email with feedback Chris@EspressoSetupBuilder.com. May your shots be perfectly extracted and milk frothy.

Want another coffee?

Take the Quiz

Start Now

For Personalized Recommendations

Discover Machines

Including Breville, Profitec, & Lelit

Discover Grinders

Including Eureka, Baratza, & Niche